Thursday, April 8, 2010


The most heartbreaking case isn't the 12 year old who was raped by her stepfather. It's not the woman who is pregnant with a very much wanted pregnancy, thanks to donor insemination, and who now has to terminate because of severe anomalies. It's not the woman who thought she was 14 weeks pregnant, but her ultrasound showed 29. I can handle those. I can handle those because I'm a helper and a fixer and if my clinic is known for anything, it's helping and fixing. But the most heartbreaking case is the woman who takes pains to reassure me, to reassure my manager, to reassure my co-worker, to reassure the doctor, that she isn't a murderer.

A couple of weeks ago, I counseled one of these women. She had told me about her dissolving marriage and her plans to return to school, she had beamed while talking about her four children at home. She had expressed sadness about having this abortion, and we talked about coping and God as a forgiving presence and compassion and the spirit of the pregnancy and I said the words, "You're still a good person." At the end of the session, she volunteered another fact that didn't fit on her medical history: "I'm not a murderer." And my heart broke.

In a world that spares no opportunity to tell women that we can't be trusted, that our bodies are not our own, and that we are monsters for wanting to have a choice, the clinic should be a safe haven. Selfishly, I live my life talking about abortion loudly and exuberantly because even though I haven't had one, I want the world to see that abortion has a face and a presence aside from the crazy people with the signs and pamphlets and plastic fetii. I study the philosophy and culture of choice so that I can inoculate clients against the myths and the anger from the world. (That inoculation sentiment is courtesy of a wonderful woman I can't link to as credit because I don't want her to the target of hate emails.)

And in spite of all the efforts of the pro-choice advocates and allies, the clinic staff, the women (and men) who tell their abortion stories, even I can't be trusted not to judge a woman. I don't want her to justify her choice to me, and I don't want her to tell me she's not a terrible person. I want her to have a safe abortion in a nurturing environment with people who trust her and for her to trust herself. She's not the enemy and neither am I.


  1. You cannot be made to feel without your consent. . .and make no mistake. . .the antis do not care about babies, women, fetuses, etc. . .they care about running your life, robbing you of your autonomy, keeping all of us indebted, broke, exasperated, and living on a subsistence existence. . ."unborn babies" are nothing but Freudian false pretenses

  2. And every week, year in, year out, we are reminded of the many faces of the enemy. They're not just the good ol' boys & girls in Washington, DC. They're the non-medical, biased volunteers at CPCs.The enemy is found in bully pulpits across several misogyntic denominations.

    And how will we recognize the enemy? The enemy's tongue is a sugar-coated serpeant that can reach out with words of sweetness. But like the cheap candy at the bottom of your trick or treat bag, it has no value. The enemy's words fail to resonate with women because their words do not take into consideration any of the complexities of women's lives. The enemy, like Satan, offers only his way such that when the sidewalk picketers proclaim they offer a better choice, they are only offering one choice--to do things their way.

    So beware of offers of a free ultrasound, a free pregnancy test, housing, money, car or "anything you need" because there will always be a string attached. The devil is just like that.

  3. This is indeed heartbreaking. If there were no anti-choicers in this world, pushing the absurd "abortion is murder" statement, women like the one mentioned here would never even consider themselves murderers. It wouldn't have crossed their minds.

  4. ".the antis do not care about babies, women, fetuses, etc. . .they care about running your life"

    This is exactly how I was when I was an anti-choicer. I'm so glad I switched sides.

    Beautiful post. Thank you!

  5. Pro choice gal: good to see change of heart. my wife and i also were on the other side once, and are embarrased by that. When they call abortion murder, i could put some pics of dead iraqi children in Haditha, a war they support as Bush was their patron saint. all of a sudden "life" is not so important.

  6. John Paul Stevens just announced his retirement. Obama will appoint for sure a pro choice/abortion advocate, somebody with a sense of social justice for people other than zygotes. I do not care if he gets re elected as most of what is important to us will be achieved by then anyway.


This is not a debate forum -- there are hundreds of other sites for that. This is a safe space for abortion care providers and one that respects the full spectrum of reproductive choices; comments that are not in that spirit will either wind up in the spam filter or languish in the moderation queue.